Blog #10
There are
several schools that are promoting the idea of "cash for grades." In
this system, children who get good grades will be given money from the school.
Discuss what you believe to be some of the negative and positive aspects of this policy.
You must respond to at least two of your classmates for this blog.
Discuss what you believe to be some of the negative and positive aspects of this policy.
You must respond to at least two of your classmates for this blog.
The
negative aspect of cash for grades would have to be that the children may just
be getting good grades for the money and not actually learning or could even
just have someone else do it for them so they can get money. While bribing
children to do good in school also can be a positive thing. They will have a
reason to make good grades and won’t just say “forget it” and wind up failing
all their classes. It used to be that earning an "A" was enough of a
reward for doing well in school. Today, in an effort to boost achievement, some
schools give students (especially those at risk for low achievement) gift cards
or high-tech gadgets. And in a surprising trend, some are rewarding students
with cash. Public schools across the country are experimenting with incentive
programs. In urban districts and rural outposts, some schools reward students
who earn higher test scores and grades. Rewarding students' efforts and
achievement with gold stars and token prizes is, of course, nothing new. Paying
them in cash is another matter. What's the short-term impact of these
cash-incentive programs on student motivation, grades and test scores? Will
this approach engage students in learning for the long haul? In my junior high school
years we were given Wii’s, game cubes, etc.
for our good grades. And it wasn’t until know that I have actually
thought about this happening in my life but knowing it did puts new thoughts in
my mind. I believe that it just depends on how you go about doing the cash or
electronics for good grades that will determine if it is positive or negative.
I do not know if I would like my child going to a school where they handed out big electronics to students that made good grades. I would want my child to know that they need to work hard throughout their life to accomplish things they really want. For example, instead of working hard to get the money at the end of each semester they should work hard so they can get scholarships to go to college.
ReplyDeleteI am not sure what would have happened if they did this where I went to school but maybe it would have made a difference. I mean some kids might just need a little more motivation. Maybe if I had a little more motivation when I was in school I would not be thirty three and just now going to college.
ReplyDelete